The Web Link-Zone
Welcome to the Link-Zone website Image Courtesy of Renjith Krishnan
2010
Appalling Loss of Police Life
Homelessness
Ethics & Scripture
Domestic Abuse What to Watch For
Salvation Army Educates Parliamentarians about Human Trafficking
Dr Gordon Moyes Condemns Lying Politicians
The High Cost of Alcohol
Guest Editorial: 10 Reasons the NSW Ethics Trial is Not a Good Idea
Editorial: Mothers and fathers replaced by homosexuals on UK birth certificates
Half a Century of Chaplains
Does TV Provide Your Family Values?
The Change We Need by Cherie Blair
VIctory for Families on not allowing same sex adoption
High cost to Health - the rigours of Divorce
2009
Healthy Lifestyle: Health habits that can help women avoid developing cancer
Why are we in Afghanistan?
Moon Landing
The right to have a mother and father serves a child's best interests
The Hidden Holocaust
Democracy the Streets of Tehran
God gave him a Hammer
Bushfires
Family Safety Plan
The Christian Response to Torture
Beatrix Potter
2008
The Lights of Spring
Egypt News: Beloved Sister of the Streets dies aged 99
How the Same Sex Bill was Lost
Genetically Engineered Canola: The Reality Behind the Myths
2007 ARTICLES
Closing Islamic Schools: Response from CVIP Readers
Reprogramming the Debate on Stem Cells
Umbilical Cord Blood
China & Human Rights
China Bows to World Pressure
The New British Prime Minister
Fathers and Aboriginal child sexual abuse
I Could Never go into Politics!
The Crescent, the Star & The Southern Cross
Should Lying Politicians be Punishable?
Christian Values from a Suprising Source!
Restrict Muslim Immigration?
FULL 2007 LIST
2006 ARTICLES

Devil in Detail: Using Embryos from Aborted Baby Girls

Renewal of Country Towns
But is it the Same?
On this day 220 years ago
The King is Coming!
The Death of the King of Tonga
THE MAKERS OF AUSTRALIA
1. The Seaborn Explorers
2. The Women
3. The Convicts
4. The Missionaries
5. The Governors
6. The Inland Explorers
7. The Educators
SERMONS
Wrestling with God
Persistent Toughness

Banner

Guest Editorial: Ten Reasons the NSW Ethics Trial is Not a Good Idea

Dr Peter Jensen,
Archbishop of the Anglican Diocese of Sydney,
originally for Southern Cross Magazine

April 2010

A trial of ethics classes in NSW schools is about to begin. Although suggestions like this have been made in the past, successive education ministers have not allowed it. The only reason it became reality this time was the personal intervention of Premier Nathan Rees, in the dying days of his incumbency.

Christians have been put onto the back foot, forced to answer the dual question, "What's wrong with teaching kids ethics" and "What's wrong with giving non-SRE children something to occupy their time as they sit idle during SRE. Some Christians will not know how to address these questions. Many schools breach SRE guidelines anyway. We must educate ourselves on this vital topic.

Thousands of volunteers and supporters of SRE in local communities have worked tirelessly in schools and receive little recognition of their extremely positive work. On the other hand, the non-religious St James Ethics Centre (SJEC) has already received wide exposure. Why? I think their support has been boosted by those who see this as a chance to break SRE and remove all trace of religion from public life.

I' m pleased to see other denominations and faiths starting to make their views known. I'd like to suggest 10 reasons why the ethics trial is a bad development and why you should urgently pray about it, then make your views known to your local MP.

Click here for the petition.  external website link

1. Mainstream ethical behaviour is taught every day in schools by existing teachers. An educational review has shown these classes are not needed.

Are we saying that teachers are not doing their job?

2. An ethics course promotes a philosophical system. The St James Ethics Centre is a self-confessed secular organisation. Why is this approach favoured?

Why not give this course a more accurate name, such as "Secular Philosophy?"

3. The reason given for trialling the course ' that non-SRE children are sitting idle' is untrue. Non-SRE children are occupied and supervised in well-managed schools. In any case, as the new classes are voluntary, how does it solve the 'problem' There will still be children neither in SRE nor this course.

4. Anglican SRE is taught mainly by local volunteers. There is a proven track record of positive community involvement. They are properly screened, trained and authorised.

Who will be the teachers of the SJEC course?

How will they be trained, what connection will they have with the school, and for how long will they keep teaching the course?

5. It is being presented as new, exciting and more useful than SRE. The result may be that fewer parents will choose SRE. But this time has been set aside for religious instruction as a recognition of the importance of this subject. Secular ethics is not an alternative. This trial is of ethics (minus God). Next it could be more maths or English. We still want children to be taught about God.

6. To be blunt, what this Government has done in approving the trial is renege on an assurance given by governments to the churches since 1880, and reaffirmed in 1990 and 2008, that it would not permit ethics or any other programs to be delivered at the same time as SRE.

How can we be sure that it does not gut SRE from the curriculum?

7. The local Parents and Citizens associations are already being compromised by being invited to support this initiative without proper consultation. The P&Cs occupy an honoured role in our society (I was once a P&C president myself!) as they support the whole school community. They are being invited to offer sectarian support for an untried initiative.

8. The study of religion is vital to an understanding of our culture, art, faith and human history. A recent survey showed that 50 per cent of Australians believe religion is important to their lives. A significantly greater number believe in God.

In the face of this, is less than an hour of SRE per school week too much to ask?

In fact, is it enough?

9. Why is St James Ethics Centre being favoured for this?

Why was a multi-faith group of primary educationists not invited to write it?

Can other providers offer the course?

If not, why not?

Why is it being offered to all students, including SRE students, as a 'complement' to SRE when it was supposed to be for non-SRE students only?

10. Be warned: if the Government allows this course to continue after the trial, it will jeopardise religious education in public schools, and without such a religious component, public schools will cease to be inclusive of all children.

We Anglicans have always been committed to public education. Any decline of SRE would make public schools less attractive to Christian parents and will accelerate the shift to non-government schools.

There are more reasons, not least the vital part which SRE plays in keeping alive a knowledge of God in our society. There will be many challenges ahead for Christians in the society of the 21st century, but few more significant than this.

 

Rev the Hon Dr Gordon Moyes AC MLC is one of Australia’s most respected Christian leaders. Ordained as a minister in the Uniting Church in Australia, he served for 27 years as the Superintendent of Wesley Mission Sydney, Australia’s largest non-government welfare provider and the world’s largest city-based church. He is also a prominent evangelist, broadcaster and elected Member of the New South Wales Legislative Council.

He became a household name in Australia many years ago when he began as host of the weekly television program Turn ‘Round Australia and radio program Sunday Night Live with Gordon Moyes.

Prime Minister John Howard characterised Dr Moyes as “the epitome of effective Christian leadership”, when describing the way he had grown Wesley Mission into one of the most dynamic and socially responsive church-based charities in the world.

Link-Zone does not necessarily endorse the views held by contributors, or by authors of linked websites. This material is provided for your information to assist you in forming your own opinion. It is Link-Zone's hope that you are able to find quality resources that will help you in your research of contemporary debates and issues. We are also unable to endorse the content of external sites linked to via the Link-Zone sites and advise that you exercise proper caution when visiting websites you are unfamiliar with.

©Link-Zone, 2000 - 2008